Writers dish about editors

I enjoyed reading this piece from The Awl written by five published authors who write candidly (sometimes very candidlycheck out Emily Gould’s piece) about their experiences with their editors. There’s so much great behind-the-scenes information in here about the publishing processhow agents work, how editors acquire books (or sometimes lose out to others), and how different each individual experience is. Even though it’s written from different points of view, this piece speaks to how unpredictable the publishing process can be. Each author makes some wise observations about what you can expect, what you might actually get, and how frustrating and/or refreshing that can be depending on where you fall on that curve! The idea that editors are overworked and that your book isn’t the only one on their list is something that authors and agents alike sometimes forget to take into consideration, so it’s a good point. It also illustrates to me how important perspective is, both in your publishing career and in anything else you do in life.

In this piece, you’re getting the scoop from those who have been through it. I hope you all find some good takeaway, or at the least an entertaining read, and ultimately see this a positive take on the publishing process. For me, even as an insider (or maybe because I’m an insider and know many of the players), there’s a lot of juicy stuff in here!

3 Responses to Writers dish about editors

  1. GhostFolk.com says:

    Hey, Stacey, if I come sit in your office will you call me while you run errands?

  2. Kristin Laughtin says:

    It's interesting how Kimmel basically says agents are motivated to get the most money out of a contract, as if that's the only factor they consider, as I can think of several posts on agent blogs about deals where they went with a smaller advance than was offered elsewhere because the rest of the terms were better. It makes one wonder whether Kimmel is speaking from his own experience and bias, whether agents were that different ten years ago, or whether those agents' posts are the exception to a general rule. It's great reading his thoughts about writing a novel for the first time, knowing it had to work because it had already been sold.

    OK, my comment's getting long, so I'll just go read what the other four authors have to say…

  3. charlotteotter says:

    Very interesting reading, thank you. I think the advice for writers to remember that theirs is not the only book on their editor's plate is really good, and I enjoyed the last writer's comments about revisions.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>